Home H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1 Reviews
H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1
Cigar Size48 × 127 mm
GaugeOuter ring = 70 gauge
StrengthMedium
Published Cigar Reviews

H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1 Tasting Summary

The H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1 may suit experienced smokers who prefer a medium to medium-full profile centered on dry wood, cedar, earth, and occasional sweetness. Its reviews suggest a traditional, savory direction rather than a consistently creamy or dessert-like character. Those seeking a mild cigar, pronounced sweetness, or dependable flavor depth may prefer a different style, since some tastings reported bitterness, cardboard, papery qualities, or a flat finish.

Wood and cedar are the most consistently reported notes across the published reviews. Cigar Aficionado’s newest tasting from 2020 emphasized cedar with citrus, minerals, intermittent chocolate sweetness, and a chalky finish. Its 2016 review also found cedar, joined by floral impressions and almonds. Earlier reviews from Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Insider more often described earth, leather, coffee, cocoa, toast, spice, and roasted nuts, showing a generally darker profile than the two newest tastings.

What distinguishes the H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1 is the reported movement between a woody foundation and contrasting accents that can feel bright, floral, nutty, earthy, or sweet. Cedar and wood provide continuity, while citrus, tea, almonds, coffee, leather, cocoa, chocolate, caramel, and toffee appear in different releases. The reviews do not present one completely uniform experience, making variation itself an important part of its documented profile. Production date, storage, age, and individual taste can affect the flavors perceived.

88.9Average Rating
18Published Reviews
92Highest Score
1996–2020Review Date Range

Score History

891996901998871999892000902001842002862004882004892005912005892006912007912009922011912012872013892016872020

Average Score by Publisher

Cigar Aficionado89.113 Reviews
Cigar Insider88.45 Reviews

Published Reviews by Source

The published reviews below cover H. Upmann Connoisseur No. 1. CCG is not affiliated with or endorsed by the publications listed. Our goal is to help readers compare scores and perspectives, with direct links to each original review.

Cigar Aficionado

13 Reviews

Though rich in color, the wrapper of this robusto is covered in kinky veins. It's a very cedary smoke with plenty of up-front citrus notes and underlying hints…

87PointsView Original Review

Overwhelming floral notes dissipate for a cedary, nutty smoke redolent of almonds. The finish is woody and dry.

89PointsView Original Review

A full, lush draw imparts a floral, tea-like smoke that picks up intensity to show roasted nuts and smoky mesquite flavors.

91PointsView Original Review

A veiny robusto that smokes evenly. The draw imparts a rich smoke to the palate, full of coffee, leather and woody notes that leave a floral finish on the pala…

92PointsView Original Review

Although the draw on this cigar is firm, the flavors are very substantial and meaty ranging from cocoa bean and earth to leather and wood. Medium to full bodie…

91PointsView Original Review

A peppery cigar with lots of coffee and leather notes. While the start is somewhat rough, the smoke improves vastly. A medium- to full-bodied cigar with a mell…

91PointsView Original Review

This cigar has a full and easy draw, and is loaded with flavor. It’s earthy and sweet, with cedar, spice and toffee notes. Full bodied.

91PointsView Original Review

This robusto burns poorly. It has dry flavors, with hints of orange peel and cedar, but has some bitter notes, and lacks depth. Medium in body.

86PointsView Original Review

A rough wrapper covers this cigar. The draw is firm. It's strong at first, but turns papery, and finishes rather bland.

84PointsView Original Review

This cigar has a light but pretty wrapper. It has a pleasant aroma, and wisps of chocolate and caramel flavor. A hint of leather develops on the finish.

90PointsView Original Review

This cigar has a solid toasty taste, with a solid core of coffee bean notes. It has a long pleasing finish, and is well-balanced.

89PointsView Original Review

A veiny, wrinkled and reddish wrapper. The cigar is fairly hearty, with hints of red clay, mint and musk. The finish is short and unimpressive, but box age wil…

87PointsView Original Review

A medium to full bodied cigar. It has a strong earthy component with leather and cocoa bean. Beautiful wrapper, and extremely well-made. Long nutty finish.

90PointsView Original Review

Cigar Insider

5 Reviews

This smoke has some leathery, creamy qualities but they are ultimately offset by cardboard notes. The cigar lacks depth, and has a flat finish.

87PointsView Original Review

A dark and oily wrapper covers this cigar. Toasty wood notes come through as well as earth and aged meat. There are light ginger spice notes on the finish.

89PointsView Original Review

This attractive, well-made cigar is spicy and woody, with leather notes and some charry character.

89PointsView Original Review

Shiny brown and smooth, this cigar has a fine draw and burn. It’s strong, with a woody aroma. Flavors are steady with a woody and wheaty finish.

88PointsView Original Review

A rough-looking cigar with a smooth, easy draw and an even burn. It has earthy tobacco flavors along with a touch of spice and chocolate. A nice finish. *June…

89PointsView Original Review
← Back to Product

 

Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

0.0 Average Rating 0 Reviews